Reproduce “Legitimate Power, Illegitimate Automation: The problem of ignoring legitimacy in automated decision systems” on OpenResearch

Turn your favorite coding agents into research agents that review literature, develop hypotheses, and run experiments.

Universal app for Apple silicon and Intel. Requires macOS 11 or later.

About this paper

Jake Stone, Brent Mittelstadt

Jake Stone and Brent Mittelstadt conceptually clarify normative legitimacy for automated decision systems (ADS), distinguishing it from public acceptance and other evaluative criteria like fairness. Their analysis systematically applies traditional philosophical theories of legitimacy, concluding that democratic authorization provides the most viable, though challenging, foundation for justifying the moral permissibility of ADS power.

Key insights

  • Legitimacy, pertaining to the moral entitlement to wield power, is a logically prior question to concerns about how that power is exercised (e.g., fairness, accuracy) in automated decision systems.
  • Intrinsic characteristics of ADS, such as opacity, embeddedness, and proprietary nature, can cause a significant divergence between public perceptions of legitimacy and the system's actual moral permissibility.
  • Democratic authorization, through representative processes and robust accountability, represents the most comprehensive and promising pathway for legitimating ADS, despite its inherent complexities.

Summary by alphaXiv.

Tip: change arxiv.org to autoarxiv.org in any arXiv abstract link to open the paper here.